Comment on "troublesome Aspects of the Renyi-Maxent Treatment"

Abstract

Plastino et al. [Plastino et al., Phys. Rev. E 94, 012145 (2016)] recently stated that the Renyi entropy is not suitable for thermodynamics by using functional calculus, since it leads to anomalous results unlike the Tsallis entropy. We first show that the Tsallis entropy also leads to such anomalous behaviors if one adopts the same functional calculus approach. Second, we note that one of the Lagrange multipliers is set in an ad hoc manner in the functional calculus approach of Plastino et al. Finally, the explanation for these anomalous behaviors is provided by observing that the generalized distributions obtained by Plastino et al. do not yield the ordinary canonical partition function in the appropriate limit and therefore cannot be considered as genuine generalized distributions.